Insurance. In the year of the affordability crisis.
Insurance content for 2026 — anchored to the year’s two dominant stories: home insurance premiums up for the fifth straight year (+46% cumulative since 2021) and the ACA enhanced premium subsidies that expired December 31, 2025. Plus Medicare’s new $2,100 Part D out-of-pocket cap, the carrier withdrawals reshaping high-risk markets, and the rise of the E&S market as last-resort coverage.
Six changes reshaping coverage in 2026.
Insurance affordability is the year’s overall story — home premiums up 46% since 2021, health premiums up sharply with ACA subsidies expiring. Medicare Part D’s $2,100 cap is the rare bright spot. Carriers continuing to withdraw from high-risk markets. The Excess & Surplus market has gone from niche to mainstream.
Home insurance up 4% in 2026
Average annual premium: $3,057 in 2026, up from $2,938 in 2025 (+4%). Since 2021, premiums have climbed 46% — three times inflation. Insurance now 9% of the typical homeowner’s monthly mortgage payment, an all-time high. Projected +8% in both 2026 and 2027.
ACA enhanced subsidies gone
The ARPA/IRA enhanced premium tax credits that capped subsidies at 8.5% of income and extended them above 400% FPL expired December 31, 2025. Out-of-pocket premiums up 75%+ on average; some households face 114% increases. About 22 million enrollees affected.
Medicare Part D $2,100 cap
The Medicare Part D out-of-pocket cap rose to $2,100 in 2026 (up from $2,000 in 2025). Average Medicare beneficiary saving over $1,500/year on medications. Insulin still capped separately at $35/month. The rare 2026 bright spot in insurance affordability.
Medicare Part B at $202.90
Standard Part B premium: $202.90/month in 2026, up $17.90 from $185.00 (+9.7%). Part B deductible: $283 (up $26). For most retirees, this consumes 32% of the average Social Security COLA increase before they see any inflation adjustment in their checks.
Carrier withdrawals persist
State Farm, Allstate, Farmers, and Safeco continue to limit or withdraw coverage in high-risk states. Worst 2025 hikes: MN +34%, CO +33%, NE +25%, OK +24%. FL avg approaching $8,500 (2× national). LA County CA avg $4,173. FL stabilizing post-litigation reform; CA still in repricing mode.
E&S market at scale
The Excess & Surplus market grew to 16% of new policies in CA/FL/TX (up from <2% in 2023). E&S carriers cover high-risk properties traditional insurers won’t — at higher prices and with fewer consumer protections. For some homeowners, it’s now the only available coverage.
All the rates and thresholds, in one place.
From Insurify’s home insurance projections, KFF’s ACA Marketplace tracking, CMS’s official Medicare fact sheets, and CFA’s ZIP-code-level pricing data. The figures that affect both your premiums and your tax-time subsidy reconciliation.
| Item | 2026 figure |
|---|---|
| Home insurance — national average | $3,057/yr |
| Home insurance — Florida average | ~$8,500/yr |
| Home insurance — LA County, CA average | $4,173/yr |
| Home insurance — cumulative increase since 2021 | +46% |
| Medicare Part B — standard premium | $202.90/mo |
| Medicare Part B — annual deductible | $283 |
| Medicare Part A — inpatient hospital deductible | $1,716 |
| Medicare Part D — out-of-pocket cap | $2,100 |
| Medicare Part D — maximum deductible | $615 |
| Medicare Part D — avg standalone premium | $34.50/mo |
| Medicare IRMAA threshold — individual | $109,000 MAGI |
| Medicare IRMAA threshold — MFJ | $218,000 MAGI |
| ACA subsidy cliff — federal poverty level | 400% FPL |
| ACA out-of-pocket maximum (individual) | $9,200 |
The 400% FPL subsidy cliff is back.
For 2021–2025, the enhanced PTC eliminated the “subsidy cliff” — even households above 400% FPL got a partial subsidy if their premiums exceeded 8.5% of income. That ended December 31, 2025. In 2026, households 1 dollar above 400% FPL lose ALL premium tax credits. For a 60-year-old in a high-cost state, that’s potentially $10,000+ per year in subsidies.
Action: If your income is near 400% FPL, plan carefully. Pre-tax retirement contributions, HSA contributions, and certain business deductions can keep you under the threshold.
Insurance, broken into the actual decisions.
Six categories covering the coverage decisions most households face — health insurance under the new ACA reality, property coverage in the crisis era, auto basics, life and disability for income protection, Medicare for those approaching or in retirement, and the specialty coverages worth considering.
Coverage in the new ACA reality
Coverage in the crisis era
Coverage for the second-biggest household premium
Protecting income
Coverage at and beyond 65
Less-common but worth considering
Run the insurance math.
Eight most-used insurance calculators — all updated for 2026 figures, the new ACA subsidy structure, and Medicare’s $2,100 Part D cap. The full set of 125 calculators is on the calculator hub.
Enrollment windows worth remembering.
Insurance is calendar-driven. Miss an open-enrollment window and you’re usually stuck until next year — except for qualifying life events that trigger Special Enrollment Periods.
A market in fundamental repricing.
The 2026 property insurance market reflects a multi-year repricing of climate risk, construction cost inflation, and decades of arguably-inadequate premium levels. Insurers paid $1.11 in claims for every $1.00 in premium in 2023 — they lost money on homeowners insurance. The current rate environment is the correction. It may not be over.
Affordability is the issue. Climate risk is the cause.
AM Best upgraded the U.S. homeowners insurance segment from negative to stable in December 2025 — the first improvement in years. But that’s profitability stabilization for insurers, not affordability relief for consumers. Premiums are projected to rise 8% in both 2026 and 2027.
Two contrasting state outcomes: Florida is stabilizing after 2021–2023 litigation reforms — 17 new insurers entered the market, and Citizens Insurance (the state insurer of last resort) is requesting a 2.6% rate decrease for 2026. California is still in repricing mode after the LA wildfires; State Farm is seeking an additional 11% increase after an emergency rate hike. Where you live and what you choose to insure increasingly matters more than how you shop.
The questions readers keep asking.
If your question isn’t here, the contact form takes editorial questions — recurring ones become their own articles.
How can I actually lower my homeowners insurance?
Several real options, ranked roughly by impact:
1. Raise your deductible. Going from $1,000 to $2,500 typically saves 10-15% annually. Going to $5,000 can save 25%. But only if you have that money in liquid savings — otherwise the premium savings is meaningless.
2. Shop around every 2-3 years. The “loyalty tax” is real — insurers raise rates more for existing customers than new ones. Get quotes from at least 3 independent agents (not captive carriers like State Farm or Allstate, who only sell their own product).
3. Bundle with auto. Typical 10-20% multi-policy discount. Worth checking, but don’t bundle if it requires accepting a worse policy on either side.
4. Mitigation discounts. Hurricane shutters, roof reinforcement, monitored security system, wildfire-resistant landscaping. Some states (FL, CA) offer substantial credits.
5. Review and reduce coverage on personal property. Standard policy includes ~50% of dwelling coverage for personal property. If you don’t have $200K of stuff, you don’t need $200K of coverage. Don’t reduce dwelling coverage — that’s the rebuild cost, not optional.
If my ACA premium tripled, should I just go uninsured?
Not as the default answer. Health insurance protects against catastrophic loss — a serious illness or accident can cost $200,000+ in medical bills. The point of insurance isn’t day-to-day costs; it’s preventing financial ruin from a low-probability, high-severity event.
That said, the new ACA reality means real trade-offs. Before deciding, work through this checklist:
1. Verify the subsidy calculation. Income estimates can be wrong. If you’ll be just under 400% FPL, you keep meaningful subsidies. Pre-tax retirement contributions, HSA contributions, and certain business deductions can keep MAGI below the cliff.
2. Consider Bronze plans. Lower premium, higher deductible. With an HSA, this often beats Silver for healthy households.
3. Look at catastrophic plans if you’re under 30 or have a hardship exemption. Very low premium, only covers catastrophic events. Better than nothing.
4. If you do go uninsured, at minimum keep an HSA (need an HDHP to contribute), shop hospital cash-pay rates, and build a meaningful emergency fund. You’re now self-insuring — act like it.
Will the ACA enhanced subsidies come back?
Maybe, but not soon. The enhanced subsidies expired because Republicans in Congress declined to extend them. Future legislative action could restore them — but for 2026 coverage decisions, you can’t count on it.
Two scenarios to plan for: extension (most likely if Democrats control Congress + White House post-2028 election; possible as part of bipartisan healthcare package), and continued expiration (most likely status quo absent major legislative push).
The CBO estimated extension would cost $250–400B over 10 years, depending on the structure. That’s a real budget conversation, not a procedural one. Plan for current law; treat any subsidy extension as upside if it happens. Don’t make 2026 coverage decisions based on hoped-for 2027 legislation.
Should I switch from Medicare Advantage to Original Medicare?
Possibly, if you’ve gotten significantly sicker since enrolling. Medicare Advantage’s network restrictions matter most when you need specialized care that’s outside the network. Original Medicare lets you see any doctor that accepts Medicare (~93% of physicians).
The catch is Medigap underwriting. If you don’t enroll in Medigap during your initial guaranteed-issue window (around age 65), you may face underwriting later — including denial or higher premiums for pre-existing conditions. Some states have additional guaranteed-issue rights (NY, CT, MA, ME).
The switch path: during Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment (Jan 1 – Mar 31) or Annual Enrollment (Oct 15 – Dec 7), you can drop MA and return to Original Medicare. Apply for Medigap immediately — but if you’ve passed your guaranteed-issue period, prepare for underwriting.
The honest framing: Medicare Advantage is often better when healthy; Original Medicare + Medigap is often better when sick. But the asymmetric switching costs (easy to enroll in MA, hard to get back to Original + Medigap) make the initial choice at 65 disproportionately important.
Is umbrella insurance actually worth it?
For households with substantial assets to protect — yes, almost certainly. A typical $1 million umbrella policy costs $200–400/year and provides coverage above your auto and homeowners limits. The ratio of protection to cost is one of the best in personal finance.
Who actually needs it: anyone with a net worth that exceeds their auto + homeowners liability limits. If you have a $500K net worth and only $250K auto liability, you’re $250K underprotected. A serious auto accident with multiple injured parties can easily exceed $1M in damages. Your assets are exposed.
Specific situations that increase the case for umbrella: teenage drivers, pool or trampoline on the property, dog (especially certain breeds), short-term rental property, rental properties, high-profile occupation, frequent guests, regular hosting of social events.
The requirements: most insurers want your underlying auto and homeowners liability at certain minimums first (commonly 100/300/100 auto, $300K home). Setting those up before adding umbrella may add cost — but the combined coverage is usually still very cost-effective for protected households.
How much life insurance do I actually need?
The DIME method is the standard starting point: Debt + Income replacement + Mortgage payoff + Education funding for children.
For a typical family with dependents: ~10–15× annual income for the primary earner. For dual-income households, both spouses usually need policies (the lost income matters; the lost child-care, home maintenance, and household management also matters).
What “10–15×” actually means in practice: if you earn $80K/year, you’re looking at $800K–1.2M in term life coverage. A healthy 35-year-old can typically get $1M of 20-year term for $30–50/month — that’s the right product for the vast majority of people.
The common over-buy: whole life insurance. Significantly more expensive than term, marketed as combining insurance + investment. The investment piece almost never beats just buying term and investing the difference. Whole life has legitimate uses (high-net-worth estate planning, special-needs trusts), but they’re narrow.
The common under-buy: “I have life insurance through work”. Usually 1–2× salary, ends when you leave the job, can’t be ported. Useful supplement; not a substitute for an individual policy.
What’s the most under-purchased coverage I should consider?
Long-term disability insurance. For working-age adults, the probability of becoming temporarily or permanently disabled is meaningfully higher than the probability of dying — but disability coverage is dramatically under-purchased.
Social Security Disability is a thin safety net (avg benefit ~$1,500/month, strict definition of disability, lengthy approval process). Most employer-provided LTD covers ~60% of base salary, capped at ~$5,000/month, and pays out only after exhausting short-term disability.
The product to look at: individual own-occupation long-term disability. “Own-occupation” means it pays if you can’t do your specific job (not “any job”). Critical for specialized professions — a surgeon who can no longer perform surgery is still able to do “some job,” but their earning power is destroyed.
Typical cost: 1–3% of annual salary for own-occupation LTD. Higher for specialized professions (physicians, dentists, attorneys). The earlier you buy, the better — premiums are based on age and health at enrollment.
Insurance overlaps with mortgage, retirement, and estate.
Three pillars that intersect directly with insurance decisions — the homeowners coverage required by mortgage lenders, the Medicare and Social Security timing decisions in retirement, and the estate-planning role of life insurance for asset transfer.
